Decision guide · insurance work

Retail vs insurance roofing estimates

The same roof can be priced two different ways. A retail estimate is your price for the work. An insurance estimate is the carrier's valuation of a covered loss, usually written in Xactimate. Mixing the two up is where most insurance-job disputes begin.

Short answer

A retail roofing estimate is priced from your own costs, price book and margin, and the homeowner agrees to it directly. An insurance estimate values the covered loss: the carrier or adjuster sets the scope, usually in Xactimate with area price lists updated monthly, and the homeowner pays the deductible. Missed items are added through supplements with photos and measurements, and upgrades beyond the approved scope are a separate retail agreement.

The two estimates side by side

Retail and insurance estimates compared
Retail estimateInsurance estimate
Who sets the priceYou, from your costs and marginThe carrier's valuation, usually in Xactimate
Who sets the scopeYou and the homeownerThe adjuster, based on covered damage and the policy
Price sourceYour price bookArea price lists, updated monthly
Who paysThe homeowner, or their lenderThe carrier, minus the homeowner's deductible
Changing itA revised estimate or change orderA supplement with documentation

Insurance terms contractors need to know

  • RCV (replacement cost value): the cost to replace the roof with like kind and quality
  • ACV (actual cash value): RCV minus depreciation; on many policies the depreciation is released after the work is completed
  • Deductible: the homeowner's share, owed under the policy
  • Supplement: a request to add items missing from the approved scope, supported by photos and measurements
  • Overhead and profit (O&P): a contractor markup the carrier may or may not include, depending on the claim

Supplements: what gets missed

Supplements are usually about scope, not price: items the first estimate left out. Common examples are code-required items, starter and ridge cap, drip edge, ice and water barrier, steep or high-roof charges, extra layers, and decking found during tear-off. Document each one with photos and measurements before you ask.

Rules that protect your license

Many states prohibit contractors from waiving, paying or rebating a homeowner's deductible, and some restrict contractors from negotiating a claim on the homeowner's behalf without a public adjuster license. Check your state's rules before you advertise insurance work.

When a homeowner wants an upgrade the carrier did not approve, such as a better shingle line, write it as a separate retail agreement they pay for, so the insurance scope stays clean.

Where MeasureRoofNow fits

MeasureRoofNow is built for the retail side and for running the job: measurement, estimates from your own price book, proposals with online signature, crews and invoicing. It does not create Xactimate estimates or ESX files. Restoration roofers who need those use Xactimate for the claim and their operating software for everything else.

Frequently asked questions

Do roofers need Xactimate?

Roofers who write insurance claim estimates or supplements usually do, because carriers and adjusters expect it. Retail-only roofers usually do not.

Is an insurance estimate the same as the contractor's price?

No. It is the carrier's valuation of the covered loss. Your contract with the homeowner should state the scope you will perform and how supplements and upgrades are handled.

Can a contractor pay the homeowner's deductible?

In many states, no. Laws in several states prohibit waiving, paying or rebating the deductible. Check your state.

Last reviewed October 27, 2026. Prices and product details change; check current terms before buying. This guide is not engineering, insurance, safety or construction advice.